Friday, March 23, 2012

Pro-Choice is NOT Pro-Abortion

After being wall bombed on Facebook a few times by well-meaning relatives who think they need to educate me about abortion, I just have to say a few things. Yes, I am pro-choice. No, that does not mean I like abortion or that I am ignorant about abortions. Yes, it's entirely possible to carry all of those views at the same time. And finally, hypocritical anti-abortion talk by those who oppose sex education and access to contraception really doesn't make for a persuasive argument.

For the record, I don't need to watch little films about aborted fetuses, or about abortion doctors who changed their own stances after years performing abortions. Neither do I need analogies between a woman's right to have access to safe abortions and a man's right to rape a woman. (Really?) I also don't need education on the "rhetoric" used by the pro-choice movement. My mom was a strong anti-abortion activist, and I held my own very one-sided anti-choice views for a number of years. I even attended Right to Life conferences! I guess what I'm getting at is that my relatives are not "teaching" me anything that I wasn't indoctrinated with taught in my youth.

It's not like I just sat down one day and decided that I love abortions or that there is anything easy about choosing to have one. However, through expanding my exposure to those with other worldviews at college, (Yes, Santorum is right. College is evil!) and through experiencing the pregnancies and births of my own children, I have come to realize that 1.) not everyone holds the same view on abortion that I do and 2.) my subjective views on abortion do not give me the right to make personal healthcare decisions for other women.

What absolutely prevents me from respecting the pro-life movement is the parallel campaign against sex education and access to contraceptives. Looking at it from the point of view that abortion is murder, these simultaneous stances make no sense. Shouldn't those opposing abortion throw everything they have into reducing the need for them?

I'm halfway through the eye-opening book The Purity Myth, which is about America's obsession with virginity and the stifling weight hefted onto the shoulders of women and girls in this country to be "sexually pure" until marriage. After I finish the book, I'd like to talk about some of the ideas it presents and the way they relate to my mom's firm "abstinence only" talks with me, as well as why it's so important that I don't repeat that pattern with Bonnie. Author Jessica Valenti says, "Abstinence-only education seeks to create a world where everyone is straight, women are regulated to the home, the only appropriate family is a nuclear one, reproductive choices are negated, and the only sex people have is for procreation." (Valenti 111.)

The above sentiment is at the very heart of the anti-choice movement as well. Otherwise there is no way these people would not advocate for a sexually educated population. Bottom line, abortion is evil but not as evil as recreational sex, right?

8 comments:

  1. "Shouldn't those opposing abortion throw everything they have into reducing the need for them?"

    Yes, but that would acknowledge what people like to do with their "naughty bits," and it makes us squirm :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very true. The irony is that humans are one of the only animals species who have sex all the time, for fun! Those advocating for procreational sex within marriage are the ones acting like wild animals. ;)

      Delete
  2. I didn't mean "us" as in I'm a pro-lifer. I am all about the choice --choices all around, in every way!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm giving you a standing ovation now! Very, very well said. Pro-choice is not pro-abortion - it's definitely more about protecting women's choice and voice over their own lives and bodies. The idea of abortion makes me very uncomfortable - but not so uncomfortable that I will force women to make the same decisions I would and although I believe I would never choose abortion for myself - there are some circumstances under which I would at least like to have the choice.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dea! I love your last sentence, and it echoes my beliefs as well. "...there are some circumstances under which I would at least like to have the choice."

      Delete
  4. Hmm, I woke up this morning and thought what will I do today? Go out for breakfast or book in for an abortion... I have been good... abortion it is!

    How about we look at the number of neglected children in the Foster Care system? And more devastatingly, the ones who don't even make it as far as that basic protection?

    Putting your baby up for adoption is quite obviously the most noble and selfless act of strength you could ever give someone else. Choosing to have an abortion, is probably the next.

    prin x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amen, Prinny! I mentioned that the group who are most vocally opposed to abortion also are the most vocally opposed to birth control and sex education, but you bring up a great point that they are also the least supportive of welfare, healthcare and other assistance for at-need children. The hypocrisy knows no bound!

      Delete
  5. I agree wholeheartedly with all that you said, Leanna. Thank you for saying it.

    ReplyDelete